The story behind "La esperanza nos está matando"

My father had so little time with his parents: He lost his mom as a young child, and his dad when he was just 21.

As a kid for me some 20-30 years later, l never fully appreciated how difficult that was for my father. How many birthdays and death days passed that weighed heavy on his heart while I was wholly ignorant of his grief.

He’d talk about them from time to time though. Mostly sad stories that pointed to a rough childhood, but he’d also talk about how he wished his dad had gotten to meet my siblings and me. He talked about camping trips “up north” that were the highlight of his youth. And he’d talked about these videos that he and 2 of his brothers (and occasionally their father) had shot with an old 8 mm camera that were stowed away in his youngest brother’s basement. He’d sometimes bemoan the lack of photos of his parents — he only had one of his mom and 2-3 of his dad — and said he hoped to one day show me those reels.

But years passed. Decades, even. And he never got to show them to me.

Fast forward to 2020 when our whole world fell apart. After losing my father slowly for years to a devastating neurodegenerative disease, we lost him altogether in 2020 right as we were ramping up a fight to get my mom on a transplant list. She fought valiantly in the midst of a global pandemic; beat the odds; and made the list. And yet just six months after we lost my father, we lost her, too.

And nestled between their two deaths — the bookends of an unfailingly cruel year — was the loss of my father’s youngest brother.

We suffered through these losses, and more, at a time when the world was shutdown. At a time when funerals were delayed, and all potential outlets to distract from our grief were closed or unsafe, particularly as one doctor told me a trauma-induced illness I developed following the loss of my parents put me at an elevated risk.

But then, some light: My cousin found those old reels when going through her father’s things and took it upon herself to digitize them by hand. And when she was finished, she did something that was especially kind: She put copies onto thumb drives and sent them to all of the cousins. That 2-inch piece of plastic became the most precious gift.

For the first time in my life, I could see the home videos my father had talked about. And the thing that surprised me the most — the thing that made me the happiest — was seeing all of the love that had been part of his family life. I could see his own father laughing and smiling and walking and skating. I could see many of his siblings (and his own grandmother!) coming together for a high school graduation party. I could see his father pretending to cry as he waved him away to college. I got to see inside his childhood home and rode along with him on some of those trips up north. And much to my surprise, the reels spanned longer than I realized and even included his courtship and subsequent marriage to my mother. A trip to the zoo with my brother and sister as small children (a few years before I made my grand entrance into the world) was the last of the reels.

I watched one video after another awash with contradiction: sadness and joy, grief and celebration. Clarity to see some of my dad’s stories come to life; confusion at the numbers of faces and places I didn’t recognize. I was beyond elated to finally get to see these reels and yet: Devastated that my father wasn’t watching them with me.

But even beyond my family connection to these videos, there was something that resonated with my inner photographer: A certain artistry in how they captured angles, motion and light. A celebration of family, this planet, and life. A living, breathing history of a bygone era.

I asked my husband, who was midway into recording an album that was spurred by the loss of my parents in the midst of the pandemic, if he was working on any songs where these reels “fit.”

He responded “yes” without pausing and told me more about the song: “La esperanza nos está matando” (“The hope is killing us”). As he finished work on it, I set about taking 2+ hours of footage that spanned nearly 2 decades and whittled it down to 4 minutes and 40 seconds. It was no easy task — there is so much wonderful footage — but I kept my focus on the song, and the pacing, and with time it all fell into place.

And in more ways than one, honestly: My parents had been so proud to be featured on the cover of my husband’s first album. My dad often wore the shirt bearing an illustration of the cover, and they had the bumper sticker proudly displayed on their car. They mostly listened to 60s rock and country music and only my father spoke Spanish and yet: They loved that little Spanish-language shoegaze album and were among my husband’s biggest fans.

Featuring them in the video for a song about their loss, on an album dedicated to them, just made sense. And yet the video isn’t just for them: It’s for all of those we have lost and those, like my father’s parents, that we never got to meet. It’s for the family and friends who endured these losses with us.

And for those beyond our circle: The ones who marvel at the passage of time. The ones who trudge through the bitter to lap up the sweet. The ones that live and breathe the melodies of the world: The discordant — and the harmonious.


Things Forgotten

One of the best gifts I’ve ever received is little more than an inch long, a fragile thing made of metal and plastic. It arrived on my doorstep two weeks ago, the hard work of a cousin who spent the last several months converting old family reels into digital files.

I knew so very little of my father’s childhood. His mom died when he was a little kid, and his dad passed not long after my father went away to college. What I knew of the years in-between was a very sad time, coping with the loss of his mother and dealing with an abusive stepmother.

My dad spoke of it sparingly, but he would occasionally make the passing remark about how he wished his dad was still around. About how he wished he’d had a chance to meet my siblings and I. I knew he played the saxophone in a band. I knew he was a railroader who was away from home a lot, and he eventually kicked out the woman when he realized how badly she was treating his three youngest kids. I knew he sometimes took my dad and his brothers on trips to lakes “up north” but never realized how frequent or full of joy those trips were (nor how far away they sometimes traveled to get there). I never knew he was the source of my dad’s silly demeanor until I saw him wipe away fake tears and pretend to be devastated when my dad was leaving for college.

Or perhaps he wasn’t really pretending.

All of my childhood, I would hear about these old family reels, tucked away at my dad’s brother’s house. But we never got to see them. Never got to see my grandfather smiling and laughing. Never got to watch this footage with someone who was there (my dad passed away three years ago, as did the brother who had these reels).

It’s been a rough three years. So much death I can hardly stand it. And most recently: a beloved aunt who was like a second mom to me passed away on Christmas.

This past week when everyone was waiting to learn whether or not a groundhog would see its shadow, I whispered a “happy birthday” to her and told her I missed her. Like all of these other recent losses, she was gone too soon. The life expectancy is dropping, and I’m seeing the data that proves it in real time. In real life.

And then we had another bittersweet day yesterday: my dad’s birthday. I had a few reasons to make a trip home to Indiana — baby hand-me-downs for a family member, a birthday present for a niece, etc. What better weekend to plan the trip than on my dad’s birthday? My entire life, no matter where I lived, I made it home for his birthday (or called that day and visited soon thereafter).

As luck would have it, we wound up staying in a lake house “up north” thanks to a friend and her kind family. It was our first time visiting this town and this lake, but being there reminded me of the reels: Was this one of the many lakes he visited with his brothers and their dad? Had they ever stood where I was standing?

I will never know for sure, just as I will never know the names of most of the people in these reels. But I know they are smiling; laughing; enjoying life. I can see they loved my father. That he was happy.

And that, as it turns out, is enough.